But Terrell made an interesting point that I hadn’t thought of:

My problem with the stealing movie themes is the complete hypocrisy of telling Hollywood (1) you are all sinners, you promote bad things, you are going to hell (although, not entirely untrue) and then saying (2) but, we like your creative, will blatantly steal it, abuse it, and don’t even think about trying to prosecute us because we “are on a mission from God” and it would look bad on CNN for you to sue us.

No wonder people think Christians are hypocrites.

So true. We shock in horror that someone would watch Desperate Housewives but then we use it as our entire series? We say “don’t be like the world” and turn around and do a cheap imitation.

Now I’m all for using pop culture, movie clips, etc. but please be original. We work with a church, a college ministry, that did a series called “The gospel according to the Simpsons”…inspired by, not copied…that was cool. Another reason that worked is because it was a one time thing. It was just a cheap spinoff, it was an inspired idea.

It’s not as easy, but it SO much more effective and above reproach. What do you think?

We serve a creative God and I believe He pours creativity into us. And yet instead of setting the pace, the church chases other people’s ideas. They steal the title of a hot TV show, create a poor rendition of the graphic and call it creative. Honestly, it’s pathetic.

I’ve heard it many times, “nothing is new“, but that doesn’t give license to steal. Instead let it remind you to take ideas, be inspired by them, and create something new. Picasso once said that “originality lay in having the most obscure sources for your ideas“…Here’s a great example that I wasn’t aware of until today. The iPod started as a pocket radio, the iMac started as a speaker….and they were all inspired by Braun.

The difference between what Apple did and what the church is guilty of is that they didn’t simply copy the pocket radio, the took inspiration from it and developed something so “new” that it changed the way people listen to music. They didn’t simply copy someone else’s idea but they brought old ideas together with new ideas to create something remarkable.

So what? Why is this important to you, to the church? Why should you be original? Here are just a few reasons:

• Okay, there’s the obvious: “Though shall not steal.” That should really be enough, but let’s keep going.
• When you steal and idea and just return a cheap rendition you look…cheap. If it’s not better than the original idea why should anyone pay attention.
• Stealing an idea breeds laziness which blinds you to new and more effective ways to communicate.
• We are called to excellence…taking someone elses idea as your own produces lukewarm results.
• Your rendition of Desperate Housewives really only impresses yourself and maybe some other churches – those that you are trying to reach are just not paying attention because there’s nothing new to pay attention to.
• Copying the latest campaign by XYZ Church that worked so well for them? Well, they developed it, researched it … it may very well not go over in your neighborhood.
• There are too many places to go for inspiration. Try the Church Markeing Lab or send me a note.
• Because original ideas stick.
  

When Steve Jobs gets ready to announce the latest Apple products remember everyone is waiting for remarkable ideas and those ideas were created through inspiration.

I’d love to hear from you. What do you think?